align SSDS and Astoria? *NOT*

2008-07-15 @ 10:17#

in Why Astoria alignment is not that trivial Soumitra Sengupta outlines some of the challenges of aliging SSDS and Astoria:

  • Astoria protocol and interaction model deals with only a single consistency domain.
  • Multi-tenancy is a fundamental concept in SSDS while Astoria has no such concept at this point in time.
  • Entities in SSDS do not require schema while default for Astoria is EDM schemas.

imho, not only is alignment non-trivial, it's not desirable.

SSDS needs to remain lightweight and flexible. EDM will kill that. SSDS does need some improvements to the query model. it *does* need improvements in it's support for other content-types (Atopm, RSS, JSON). but SSDS does not need to become another member of the Entity Framework system.

SDS